But when issuers expect high returns, they prefer interest based financing such as conventional bonds to maximize their gains in case of success. Sukuk and bonds are two kinds of financial instruments. This paper investigates the impact of conventional bonds and. Some of the important points have been listed below. Mean yield of sukuk and that of conventional bond are significantlydifferent for all forms of securities issued by bank negara malaysia. However, the descriptive statistics show that the average coupon rate on sukuk is higher than for conventional bonds 4. Sukuk adhere to an islamic view of finance, avoiding riba generating money from money, i.
With regard to the issuer choice between sara sukuk and conventional bonds, panel b of table 6 reports that older and larger firms prefer to issue conventional bonds rather than sara sukuk. Feb, 20 however, the debate among scholars in distinguishing sukuk from its conventional counterpart is still ongoing. Though a benefit based sukuk is a securitization of the advantages which is nearer in structure to a conventional bond. Similarities of sukuk and conventional bond both sukuk and. Returns on sukuk derive either from performance of an.
Difference between sukuk and conventional bond coursebb. Difference between islamic bond sukuk and conventional bond. Significant difference in the yields of sukuk bonds versus. On the other hand, investors in the sukuk corporate bonds receive slightly lower returns discount of about 25. Similarities of sukuk and conventional bond both sukuk and conventional bonds can be rated by any of the rating agencies. Rather, sukuk can be defined as certificates of equal value representing undivided shares in. A comparative study of conventional bonds and islamic sukuk and. We have also introduced various types of sukuk offered in islamic finance along. The difference between means is a positive figure, indicating that islamic securities tend to yield more than conventional bonds issued by. It is also called an islamic bond, but this definition requires additional explanation of key differences between the two products. Moreover, we excluded the banking and insurance sector julio et al. At first blush, sukuk and conventional bonds seem different in name only, but a deeper look.
Testing is done by using the average, standard deviation, coefficient of correlation, covariance of the portfolio, as well as the statistical test t. Instead, sukuk should be seen as investment certificates with claims on assets and the right to a share of the cash flow that accrues from the ownership of the assets. Also, we restricted the study to gcc countries because more than 90% of the remaining sample was sukuk and conventional bonds. Such sukuk are regarded as very low risk investments. Sukuk give the investor partial ownership in the asset on which the sukuk.
These similarities have been highlighted so the financial press has described these securities to be similar to conventional bonds, despite important differences of these securities. Because sukuk are assetbased securities not debt instruments they fit the bill. The ftse sukuk index measures the performance of global islamic fixed income securities, also known as sukuk. The sukuk are based on the underlying tangible assets that the spv has acquired rather than being debt securities, which is the case with the issuance of conventional bonds. Sukuk are defined by the aaoifi accounting and auditing organization for islamic financial institutions as securities of equal denomination representing individual ownership interests in a. In other words, sukuk represent ownership in a tangible asset, usufruct of an asset, service, project, business, or. Sukuk can resemble conventional bonds in some aspects, but they are technically neither debt nor equity. Apr 15, 2016 difference between conventional bond and islamic bond sukuk distinguishing sukuk from conventional bonds conventional bonds sukuk asset ownership bonds dont give the investor a share of ownership in the asset, project, business, or joint venture they support. A stock market perspective article pdf available in journal of comparative economics 4. The breakdown distinguishes sukuk and conventional bonds.
However, the credit rating is about the stability of the underlying asset and the volatility that the buyer may face. In fact, several similarities exist between sukuk and bonds. The average yields of sukuk treasury bonds are significantly higher premium than that of conventional treasury bonds. The buyer can pay the price on the spot or establish deferred payment terms paying either in installments or in one future lump sum payment. Bonds dont give the investor a share of ownership in the asset, project, business, or joint venture they support. Islamic bonds sukuk emerged as an innovative capital market instrument over the last decade. In the case of conventional bonds the issuer has a contractual obligation to pay to bond holders, on. Sukuk market development and islamic banks capital ratios.
However, the debate among scholars in distinguishing sukuk from its conventional counterpart is still ongoing. Consequently, the issuance size of sukuk has declined and conventional bonds have benefitted accordingly. However, he noted that malaysias declining share of global issuance reflects the increasing internationalisation and diversity of islamic capital markets. Another major difference between sukuk and conventional bonds is asset ownership which is borne out of the general structures of islamic finance products. In english the word sukuk is uniplural, so one sukuk, two sukuk etc. Given that the focus is only on corporate sukuk conventional bonds, we excluded sovereign sukuk sovereign conventional bonds. The only difference pointed out is that regulations consistent with islamic principles of financial trading apply to sukuk bonds. This present research aims at examining the comparative study between the sukuk, a new financing product and conventional bond. Basics of sukuk1 sukuk is popularly known as an islamic or sharia compliant bond whilst in actual fact, it is an assetbacked trust certificate. Sukuk versus bonds recently, one of the aaiofis top sharia scholarsin his seminal paper has rightfully criticized the existing sukuk issues in terms of their violation of the sharia standards. Conventional bond is a debt obligation issued by the sovereign or corporation in order to obtain financial resources. Corporate bonds and sukuk issues developing the market in maldives corporate bonds and sukuk issues developing the market in maldives rabel akhund 7 may 2008 male corporate bonds bond is a debt instrument. Corporate choice between conventional bond and sukuk. Objective research on sukuk bond a new financing product.
It is complex to understand the exact nature of sukuk and to differentiate them from bonds. The debt management office dmo nigeria is a government agency established to centrally coordinate the management of nigerias debt. A sukuk is an islamic financial certificate, similar to a bond in western finance, that complies with sharia islamic religious law. Compare and contrast sukuk islamic bonds with conventional. Aaoifi also distinguishes sukuk from conventional bonds by emphasizing that sukuk are not claims on cash flows and cannot be based on a pool of receivables. Since then, sukuk have been growing in popularity and have been utilised by both corporate sector and states for raising financing. Regulatory problems and possible solutions pdf download available from. As at 2011, malaysia was the highest global sukuk issuer by issuing 69 percent of worlds total issuances. A comparative analysis of sukuk and conventional bonds. Both sukuk and bonds in some cases may have the same characteristics. These are certificates which are offered by corporations and governments which follow islamic principles. The key differences between sukuk and conventional debt instruments bonds are.
This thesis found that even when sukuk and conventional bonds have fundamental differences. However, when we talk about the context of islamic finance and its instrument, it is certainly not free from the rules of islamic law as other muamaalat chapters, from where appears significant difference between conventional sukuk and islamic sukuk, especially those in the. Sukuk provides access to a vast and growing islamic liquidity pool in addition to the conventional debt. Oct 09, 2017 conventional bond vs sukuk amila nahar. Unlike bonds, sukuk are not technically debt instruments although they are treated as such for regulatory purposes in some jurisdictions. The authors conclude that sukuk instruments seem to provide valuable portfolio diversification benefits due to their lower volatility and dynamic correlation paths. Bonds can be issued to finance any legal pu rpose the sale of a bond is the sale of a debt. Nov 04, 20 a sovereign sukuk is a sukuk where the obligor the owner in the above diagram is a sovereign entity, typically a state such as the united kingdom if it proceeds to issue a sukuk. Theyre a debt obligation from the issuer to the bond holder. This paper aims at assessing the potential difference between sukuk and conventional bonds by capturing any additional diversification benefit that can be gained by adding sukuk in to conventional fixed income portfolio. Feb 26, 2014 in this story sukuk is discussed, along with its origin and basic structures. Sukuk and conventional bond securities have some similarities that probably prompted practitioners, mass media journalists,even some academics to consider sukukas being similar to conventional bonds.
Sukuk and indirect holding in conventional bonds 22. A sukuk investor has a common share in the ownership of the assets linked to the investment although this does not represent a debt owed to the issuer of the bond. Sukuk are the financial certificates which are termed as an islamic equivalent bond watkins, 2011. Sukuk are in many aspects similar to conventional eurobonds.
Sukuk can resemble conventional bonds by some of its features, but it is technically neither debt nor equity. They are designed to have economic implications for the issuer and the investor which are essentially similar to tradable bonds, but without having any interest paid or received. However, this representation is not altogether correct. Sukuk are also subject to credit rating just like bonds. Five important differences between sukuk and traditional. Comparative analysis of return on sukuk and conventional bonds. The first aim is to study the advantages and disadvantages between and conventional sukuk bonds. This study aims to analyze the ratio between yields on sukuk and conventional bonds using model calculations yield to maturity ytm and portfolio optimization model markowitz model and single index model. Ram rating services bhd ceo foo su yin says the total issuance of sukuk corporate bonds in 2012 was rm 71. Instead, the sukuk alijarah structure uses the leasing contract as the basis for the returns paid to investors, who are the beneficial. In the case of restructuring or its application, islamic sukuk is not much different from the conventional sukuk bonds. The funds raised from sukuk issuance must be used only for ethical purposes the sale of sukuk represents the sale of the holders interest in an asset. We employ standard event study methodology to examine the stock price reaction to the issuance announcements of 237 islamic bonds. Jul 26, 2014 sukuk adhere to an islamic view of finance, avoiding riba generating money from money, i.
Sukuk al murabaha cost plus or deferred payment sukuk a murabaha contract is an agreement between a buyer and seller for the delivery of an asset. The title chosen for this research project is comparison between performance of sukuk and conventional bond in malaysia. Islamic investors want to balance their equity portfolios with bond like products. Both sukuk and bonds can have some particular features. In his view most majority of todays sukuk are very similar to the conventional bonds. Conventional bonds are structured on the basis of debt whereas sukuk are basically investment certificates consisting of ownership claims in a pool of assets. We have also introduced various types of sukuk offered in islamic finance along with the mechanism and relevant examples. It is the trust certificate, which gives its holder an undivided proportion of ownership in the underlying projectasset and right to receive cash flows from this underlying. The difference between means is a positive figure, indicating that islamic securities tend to yield more than conventional bonds issued by bank negara malaysia, ceteris paribus. May 20, 20 in the case of restructuring or its application, islamic sukuk is not much different from the conventional sukuk bonds.
We further examine the effects of issuance announcement on shareholder wealth in multiple economic settings, precrisis, during the crisis, and postcrisis, using the. Sukuk are also considered to serve as security instruments that provide a predictable level of return fixed or floating. Instead of applying interest to the holders like conventional bonds, the issuer will offer profitsharing scheme based on the. Sukuk securities have some similar features with bond securities. We employ standard event study methodology to examine the stock price reaction to the issuance announcements of 237 islamic bonds sukuk versus 231 conventional bonds issued in twelve financial markets from 2005 to 2017. Sukuk as a tool for infrastructural development in nigeria. Sukuk involves asset ownership while bonds are debt obligations. Comparison between the performance of sukuk and conventional bond in malaysia xv preface this research paper is submitted as a part of the requirement to fulfill for the bachelor of finance hons course. How sukuk islamic bonds differ from conventional bonds. Dec 25, 2014 aaoifi also distinguishes sukuk from conventional bonds by emphasizing that sukuk are not claims on cash flows and cannot be based on a pool of receivables. Thus, claim embodied in sukuk is not simply a claim to cash flow but also an ownership claim.
An initiative for the enhancement and development of the islamic financial market by means of free access to a comprehensive sukuk database, latest market news as well as a database of qualified industry professionals and services firms. Resource upheld sukuk are such where a real deal has occurred and the spv controls the fundamental resource. Corporate choice between conventional bond and sukuk issuance. Islamic bonds called sukuk the word sukuk is an arabic word which means certificate. According to imf, sukuk is the most popular modern islamic financial instrument4. There are five important differences between sukuk and traditional bonds. Are sukuk securities the same as conventional bonds.
In this story sukuk is discussed, along with its origin and basic structures. Conventional bonds a bond is a contractual debt obligation whereby the issuer is contractually obliged to pay to bondholders, on certain specified dates, interest and principal, whereas, the sukuk holders claims an undivided beneficial ownership in the underlying assets. Index 1 basics of sukuk 2 difference between conventional bond and sukuk 3 sukuk in detail 4 typical international sukuk mechanism 5 sukuk structures page 2 3. Comparison between islamic sukuk and conventional bonds.
Contrary to some perceptions, important difference s. Sukuk can resemble conventional bonds by some of its features, but it has different underlying structure and provision. Are islamic bonds different from conventional bonds. Sukuk in their modern islamic finance form were invented in malaysia around the year 2000. The index covers us dollardenominated, investmentgrade sukuk that are shariacompliant and issued in the global markets. Difference between conventional bond and islamic bond sukuk distinguishing sukuk from conventional bonds conventional bonds sukuk asset ownership bonds dont give the investor a share of ownership in the asset, project, business, or joint venture they support.
Modern sukuk emerged to fill a gap in the global capital market. Sukuk typically represent an undivided beneficial ownership interest in certain tangible assets save for certain receivables, such as zhimam or duyun, the usufruct of an asset or certain projects or investment activities. Bond bonds represent a pure debt obligation due from the issuer. Pdf on account of the prohibition of interest riba, islamic finance is. There are structures other than sale and leaseback which can be used to issue sukuk. Shareholder wealth perspective abstract this paper investigates whether the stock market reacts differently to the issuance of fixedrate sukuk as compared to fixedrate conventional bonds and hence, if there is a difference in the.
712 815 369 67 597 358 45 872 465 1235 541 1080 1265 614 315 221 447 467 1169 51 875 276 757 514 959 310 695 592 1474 635 1179 810 257 395